The deals you are holding up yourself
What lives in one head cannot be repeated without it. A written criterion has three parts: the question, the threshold and what you do when it isn't met.
Do we take this special order even if it throws production off? Do we keep chasing this quote or let it go? Is this client worth it, or will they cost us more than they bring? In many companies that already sell well, and that even have a board, those questions have a single way out: «ask the owner».
And the owner almost always gets it right. Years of reading the business, knowing the clients, knowing which order will bring trouble before the purchase order even lands. That very accuracy is what makes the problem hard to see: while the decisions turn out well, nobody asks what it costs the company that all of them come out of the same head.
Why your team doesn't decide without you
Michael Polanyi put it this way: we can know more than we can tell. His example is simple: we recognize a person's face among thousands, but almost nobody could explain how. That is an owner's commercial instinct: knowledge tested a thousand times in practice that has never had to be put into words. The owner looks at an order and knows whether it's worth it; explaining why costs considerably more than deciding.
Out of that comes a very common frustration. The owner asks the team to use its judgment, the team decides differently from how the owner would have, and the conclusion is «nobody here has any judgment». So the owner goes back to making every decision, now convinced nobody else can.
That judgment never left the owner's head. The team sees the decision, but not what the owner looked at to make it: that client's payment history, or the week the plant is already full. It copies the result without knowing where it came from, and with the next case, similar but different, it gets it wrong. Every mistake confirms to the owner that it's better to decide personally, and the circle closes.
It works wonderfully as long as the owner is there. The problem shows up when they're not, when the company grows faster than their calendar, or when someone from outside asks how commercial decisions get made here. What lives in one head cannot be repeated without it.
When the owner decides case by case, the team gets opinions that work for that order, that client, that day. And since every answer comes out different, the team learns the only thing it can learn from that: you have to ask. That's how the line forms outside the owner's office.
A criterion says what you decide with, and it has three parts: the question it settles, the threshold that separates yes from no and what you do when it isn't met.
Here's how it would look with the special order. Is it worth it? Yes, if it leaves at least the margin of a normal order and doesn't push back anyone else's delivery. If it doesn't meet that, it gets quoted at the real cost of the change, or escalated, numbers in hand. The owner keeps deciding the hard cases, and now they arrive with the information needed to settle them fast.
Writing that criterion down forces the owner to do something they almost never do: explain to themselves why they decide the way they decide. That's where thresholds appear that were crystal clear, and others that had never been considered.
What a company that depends on its owner is worth
This weighs more than it seems. In a survey of executives about what holds back growth, 85 % pointed to internal obstacles before the market or the competition, and among them is decision-making that gets slower and more complicated.
When a company loses speed, the conversation usually goes outward: competitors cut prices, clients are buying less, the sector is flat. Sometimes that's true. But before blaming the market, it's worth counting how many commercial decisions are waiting their turn on one person's calendar.
And seen from a board, it has a price. People who value companies apply a discount when the business depends on a person who is hard to replace; Shannon Pratt put it between 10 % and 25 % of value. The day someone wants to invest, partner or buy, one of the first questions will be how much of this business works without the owner, and there the instinct, however good, shows up in no financial statement.
That is why this conversation belongs to the board as much as to the owner. A board asks about risk, continuity and value, and depending on a single head for commercial decisions touches all three.
Get it out of your head
I love an owner with good instincts; it's among the most valuable things a company can have. Precisely for that reason it has to come out of the head and onto paper: so that what you do well can be repeated, scaled and let go of, and so the owner is free for the decisions that truly only they can make.
And mind you, it doesn't all have to be written at once. You start with the decision that piles up the most: the one that lands on your desk most often, or the one that holds up your team the longest.
What is tacit cannot be taught, cannot be repeated and cannot be scaled.
Which commercial decision piles up the most on your calendar, and what would the criterion have to say for your team to make it without you?